The question needs no explanation, and that may be the most remarkable thing about it. Gilligan’s Island premiered on CBS in September 1964 and ran just three seasons and 98 episodes, yet 62 years later you can still say “Ginger or Mary Ann?” at a backyard barbecue and every man over 50 will have an answer ready. Tina Louise played Ginger Grant, the movie star in the slinky gowns. Dawn Wells played Mary Ann Summers, the farm girl from Kansas in gingham and short shorts.
Fans have been arguing about the two of them ever since, but the people who actually lived on that soundstage lagoon were asked the question too, over and over, for the rest of their lives. Their answers were surprisingly consistent, with one very notable exception.
Why Was Mary Ann Left Out of the Theme Song?

Before anyone could pick Mary Ann, they had to know her name, and in the first season the show did not bother to sing it. The opening theme ran through the Skipper, Gilligan, the millionaire and his wife and the movie star, then ended with “and the rest are here on Gilligan’s Isle.” Russell Johnson, who played the Professor, never forgot it. “We were both neglected in the opening credits and referred to as ‘the rest,'” he wrote of himself and Wells in his 1993 memoir Here on Gilligan’s Isle.
It was Bob Denver who fixed it. As Tom Shales recounted in The Washington Post in 2004, Denver lobbied Sherwood Schwartz and the network to change the lyrics, and he reportedly told them that if Johnson and Wells were not named, they could take his name out too. From the second season on, the chorus sang “the Professor and Mary Ann.” Schwartz later admitted that leaving her out had been a mistake, as TODAY noted in 2012. Once viewers had a name to write on an envelope, the mailbags told their own story.
Who Really Got More Fan Mail, Ginger or Mary Ann?

Wells expected to lose this contest. According to MeTV, she assumed Tina Louise would draw the most letters as the show’s movie star. She was wrong. A 1999 Pittsburgh Post-Gazette profile reported that Wells received more fan mail than her co-star, and Wells said on TODAY in 2014 that Mary Ann got more mail than any other character on the show.
Lloyd Schwartz, Sherwood’s son, went further. Wells “got five times the fan mail than everybody else,” he told Fox News Digital in 2022. The figures come from the people who were there rather than from any published tally, so the exact ratio is anyone’s guess, but every one of them points the same way.
Wells had a theory about who was writing. Girls, she told the Post-Gazette, saw Mary Ann as a role model they could relate to. Boys wrote for a different reason. “Mary Ann would be the one that you would trust,” she said. “Mary Ann was your first crush. She was the first girl you would kind of fantasize about when you were 12 or 13 because she was the good girl.” Ginger, by comparison, was “so much more worldly,” and a boy might be “a little terrified to approach a Ginger.”
That idea of a boy being scared of Ginger turned out to be one Gilligan himself agreed with.
What Did Bob Denver and the Professor Say?

Denver never pretended to be neutral. When U.S. News & World Report asked him the eternal question a few years before his death in 2005, he called it no contest. He liked Mary Ann better, and he said that whenever there were polls, Mary Ann beat Ginger by about three to one. “I think Ginger just scared the guys,” he explained.
He made the same case on survival grounds when Survivor was the hottest show on television. “There’s no doubt in my mind that Mary Ann would be the Survivor,” Denver told Broadcasting & Cable in August 2000. “Ginger and the Howells could never hack it.” Mary Ann’s cooking and sewing, he added, were “definitely the reason the rest of us survived.”
The polls he mentioned were real enough. When Russell Johnson toured Toronto with his memoir in 1993, the Toronto Sun noted that a USA Today poll had just given Wells’ character 85 percent of the vote. Johnson himself was too much of a gentleman to cast a ballot in print, but he did not hide where his heart was. “I guess if I had to identify the one I was closest to in the cast, it would be Dawn,” he wrote, calling their friendship “a mutual fondness” that “was always platonic.” He also said Wells was “very much like Mary Ann: kind, gentle, and extremely good with children.”
Even the man who created both women leaned one way, though for his own reasons. Sherwood Schwartz, who later laughed off the theory that his castaways were the seven deadly sins, told the website Retrocrush in 2003 that “my favorite from a producer perspective was Mary Ann,” as SlashFilm later reported. His explanation was about the workday rather than the swimsuits. “Tina had a certain amount of temperament,” he said.
How Did Dawn Wells Feel About Always Winning?

Wells could have grown tired of being half of a barroom argument. She chose to enjoy it instead. In a 2014 interview with the Vancouver Sun, she said she owned a T-shirt reading “Ginger or Mary Ann, the ultimate dilemma.” Then she added, “You can go anywhere and say ‘Ginger or Mary Ann?’ You don’t have to say what show it is. Everybody gets it. And I always win.”
She understood exactly why. “The Mary Ann-Ginger issue is always there,” she told the Television Academy Foundation in 2008. “You had to be a real man to understand Ginger, and Mary Ann would’ve gone to the prom with you.” Grown men stopped her for decades to tell her the same thing. “A lot of guys would come up to me and say I married a Mary Ann,” she said. Wells died of complications from COVID-19 on December 30, 2020, at 82, and she was Mary Ann to her fans right to the end. Our earlier look at why Tina Louise skipped every reunion covers how the two actresses actually got along off camera.
What Does Ginger Herself Say?

That leaves one vote uncounted, and it belongs to the only castaway still with us. Tina Louise, born February 11, 1934, is 92 and the last surviving member of the main cast. She has spent much of her life declining to discuss Ginger at all, but when U.S. News ran Denver’s three-to-one verdict and his theory that Ginger scared the guys away, it printed her reply right beside it.
“I don’t think so!”






45 Years After Luke and Laura’s ‘General Hospital’ Wedding, The Backstory Fans Still Can’t Shake