Seventy years ago this week, a 40-foot cutout of Elvis Presley in a cowboy hat towered over the marquee of New York’s Paramount Theatre. Love Me Tender had its premiere there on November 15, 1956, and 20th Century Fox opened it across the country on November 21 with 575 prints, far more than the 200 to 300 a studio usually struck. Elvis was 21, the hottest singer in America, and nobody at Fox was quite sure yet whether he could act.
He had a bigger problem than his reviews. The movie he made was a Civil War Western with a sad ending, and his own fans fought it before they had even bought a ticket. Off camera, Elvis was busy losing his heart to his leading lady, and that is the part of the story that still has a twist left in it, 70 years on.
How Did ‘The Reno Brothers’ Turn Into ‘Love Me Tender’?

The picture started life as The Reno Brothers, a modest Western about a Texas family pulled apart by the war, and Elvis was loaned to Fox by Paramount for a supporting part as Clint, the youngest brother who stays home. Then he sang the ballad from the film on his first Ed Sullivan Show appearance on September 9, 1956. According to Elvis Australia and WKNO in Memphis, advance orders for “Love Me Tender” topped one million before the single was even in stores, the first time that had ever happened, and Fox renamed the movie after the song.
The credits still put him third. Richard Egan, who played older brother Vance, got top billing, Debra Paget came second as Cathy, and the credits read “and introducing Elvis Presley.” The AFI Catalog and TCM both note it was the only time in his film career that he didn’t get top billing. Elvis memorized the whole script, other actors’ lines included, and he surprised Hollywood columnist Army Archerd by singing the title song for him quietly in the music bungalow. “People think all I can do is belt,” he told Archerd. “I used to sing nothing but ballads before I went professional.”
Egan was won over, too. “This guy is genuine,” he told The New York Times, according to American Songwriter. “There’s nothing phony about him and he works hard. He’s not conceited.” What the cast also knew was how the script ended for Clint, and word of it was already leaking out.
Why Did Fans Protest Before They Saw It?

Clint dies. He is shot in the final showdown and dies in Cathy’s arms, and once fan magazines printed the rumor, Fox had a revolt on its hands. Elvis Australia and TCM both report that the studio filmed an alternate ending in which Clint survives, then threw it out. Some fans turned up at the Paramount unveiling carrying placards that complained about the death scene, which was quite a thing to protest about a movie they hadn’t seen yet.
The compromise is the scene people remember. Fox kept the death, but Elvis was called back to record an extra verse, and as the Reno family walks slowly away from Clint’s grave, a ghostly close-up of him singing “Love Me Tender” is superimposed over the shot. It didn’t spare his mother. Gladys Presley reportedly cried when her son’s character died at a private screening at Loew’s State in Memphis on November 20, the night before the national release.
Could Elvis Really Act?

The critics split. Time was cruel enough to ask whether his face was “a Walt Disney goldfish,” while the Los Angeles Times told readers, “Elvis can act. S’help me the boy’s real good, even when he isn’t singing.” The audience didn’t care either way. Jerry Schilling, the Memphis kid who later joined Elvis’s inner circle, remembered that “the screams of the girls around me made it just about impossible to follow the story.”
The money settled the argument. A November 1956 Hollywood Reporter item, cited by AFI and TCM, said Love Me Tender earned back its roughly $1.2 million cost just two weeks after its national release, a record at the time, and it went on to about $4.5 million in rentals. Elvis would make 30 more feature films and never again took third billing. Off the set, though, the romance he wanted most from that first picture was going nowhere.
What Happened Between Elvis And Debra Paget?

Paget was 23, a Fox contract player since her teens, and she had not expected much. “Before I met him, I figured he must be some sort of moron,” she admitted in Peter Guralnick’s biography Last Train to Memphis, and Ray Connolly’s account of the shoot for the Daily Mail tells the same story. Elvis was smitten anyway and followed her around the set. Her mother was usually there with her, and the papers had already linked her romantically to Howard Hughes. You can read more about their on-again, off-again friendship in our archive.
Decades later, Paget finally said out loud what the King had asked her. In a 1997 interview reported by TCM and Wikipedia’s biography of the actress, she said Elvis proposed marriage after Love Me Tender. The wedding never happened. Paget, who had just played Lilia in The Ten Commandments, married three times instead, the last to oilman Louis Kung in 1962, and she left Hollywood soon after her final film, The Haunted Palace, came out in 1963. In the 1990s she hosted her own program on the Trinity Broadcasting Network.
She turned 93 on August 19, and she is the last of the three names on that poster still with us, since Elvis died in 1977 and Richard Egan in 1987. Reports in recent years place her in Texas, where she moved after marrying Kung, a long way from the studio that signed her as a teenager. She was also the first leading lady Elvis Presley ever fell for, and the one who never fell back.






The Only ‘Rocky’ Cast Members Still Alive Today