In the spring of 1971, ABC and the show’s sponsor, Clairol, wanted That Girl to go out the way so many sitcoms did, with a wedding. Marlo Thomas said no. Ann Marie stayed engaged to Donald and never walked down the aisle, and the woman who played her stayed single for nearly another decade herself. Thomas turns 89 today, Saturday, November 21. She was born Margaret Julia Thomas in Detroit on that date in 1937, the oldest child of the comedian Danny Thomas.
She finally married at 42, and her reasons for waiting had very little to do with romance and a great deal to do with the people who raised her. “I didn’t get married until I was 42 years old,” she told Yahoo Life in 2022, and she has spent the years since explaining exactly why that was no accident.
Why Wouldn’t She Let Ann Marie Walk Down the Aisle?

That Girl premiered on ABC in September 1966, and for five seasons Ann Marie was something television had rarely tried. She was a single young woman who left her parents in Brewster, New York, to chase an acting career in Manhattan, and the show treated her ambitions as the point. Thomas also produced the show, so when the network and Clairol pressed for a wedding finale, she could push back. She allowed Ann and Donald, played by Ted Bessell, to get engaged at the start of the final season, and that was as far as she would go.
The last episode aired in March 1971, and instead of a ceremony, Ann took her fiancé to a women’s liberation meeting. Thomas told Yahoo Life she didn’t want her character to get married at the end of the show because “it would have been a betrayal to all the girls and the women who had followed her.” The girls watching at home didn’t know it then, but their heroine’s real life was running on the same principle.
What Did Her Mother’s Choice Have To Do With It?

Thomas grew up in a loud, funny household in Beverly Hills, with a father who was one of the biggest stars on television and a mother, Rose Marie, who had been a singer before she married him in 1936. Rose Marie gave that career up to raise Marlo, her sister Terre and her brother Tony. Danny Thomas, meanwhile, kept a promise he had made as a struggling young comic when he prayed to St. Jude Thaddeus, and in 1962 he opened St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital in Memphis.
Marlo admired her mother and never stopped feeling the cost of what she gave up. “I wish she hadn’t had to make that sacrifice,” she told AARP in 2011, adding that during the women’s movement of the 1970s, “the fact that my mother had given up so much played in the back of my head all the time.” She marched and lobbied for other women in those years, and in many ways, she said, she was doing it for Rose Marie.
That history made her wary of becoming anyone’s wife. “I was always scared of marriage,” she told People in 1977, because she believed she “would have to become another person.” She poured that energy into work instead, and today she is still National Outreach Director at the hospital her father founded. So what happened to the woman who swore marriage would change who she was?
Who Finally Changed Her Mind?

In 1977, Thomas went to Chicago to promote her film Thieves on The Phil Donahue Show. Donahue, a divorced father raising four teenage sons, couldn’t hide how taken he was with his guest. “You are really fascinating,” he told her on the air, and she answered that she found him loving and generous. “We just clicked,” she later said. “I just loved his confidence.”
He was nervous, too. “It didn’t happen overnight. I was scared,” Donahue told CBS News in 2010, and he understood what he was asking of her. “I mean, five children. Come on, ‘Here honey, here’s five kids.'” Thomas, who had told the same program she was “completely against” marriage, added three words that explain the next 44 years: “But never say never.” The couple wed on May 21, 1980. It was her first marriage and his second, and Donahue eventually moved his show from Chicago to New York so they could build their life there.
She had no children of her own and walked into a house full of teenage boys, along with his daughter, Mary Rose. She decided right away not to compete with their mother. “From the very first day, I decided that I was not going to try to be a ‘mother’ to Phil’s children in the traditional sense,” she told AARP. She would be their friend instead, as Rose Marie had been a friend to her, and those friendships, she said, were “as strong today as they were 30 years ago.” You can meet all five of them in our look at the children of Phil Donahue and Marlo Thomas.
What Did She Say About Him in the End?

In 2020 the couple wrote What Makes a Marriage Last together, interviewing 40 long-married couples about how they did it. Donahue died on August 18, 2024, at 88, after a long illness. “I lost my sweetheart last night,” Thomas wrote on Instagram the next morning.
She kept a low profile for months afterward. When she returned to NBC’s Today in November 2025 to talk about a new research building at St. Jude, she said simply, “I miss him a lot.” She has stepped out a few times since, including a Broadway opening night in June with Candice Bergen and Diane Sawyer, which we covered in her rare night out.
That same month, in the 60th anniversary year of That Girl, Emmy magazine asked her about meeting Phil Donahue on his own show.
“I was sure within 10 minutes of the interview that this was the guy.”






Juliet Mills Says ABC Never Let Nanny Fall For The Professor, But She’s Been Married To Maxwell Caulfield For 45 Years