Eve Plumb, remembered by many as Jan Brady from The Brady Bunch, recently showed a side of herself that few expected. At 67, she took the stage at New York City’s 54 Below and delivered a performance so strong that fans are now questioning why she never pursued Broadway earlier in her career.
Her rendition of “You’re a Liar” from Lucille Ball’s 1961 musical Wildcat was a revelation. This Broadway moment highlighted her sharp comedic instincts, vibrant stage presence, and vocal power. It wasn’t just a nostalgic performance; it felt like the arrival of a seasoned musical theater star.
A Standout Moment For The Former TV Star
@mattnyc78 Eve Plumb (The Brady Bunch) and John Bolton sing “You’re a Liar” From Lucille Ball’s 1961 Broadway musical, “Wildcat” at 54 Below on 7/28/25 #LucilleBall #54Below #broadway #musicaltheater #musicaltheatre #theater #theatre ♬ original sound – mattnyc78
According to Parade, Plumb performed alongside Broadway veteran John Bolton, and their chemistry brought the number to life. Her animated delivery honored Lucille Ball while adding her own unique style. As a result, the duet felt fresh yet deeply respectful of its origins.
Fans immediately shared their reactions online, and praise poured in. Many called it a “Broadway-caliber” performance, while one viewer declared, “She should have had a Broadway career all along.” For longtime Brady Bunch fans, this Eve Plumb Broadway performance felt like uncovering a hidden talent they had never truly seen before.
Confidence And Experience On Full Display
What made the evening even more impressive was Plumb’s confidence. Decades of experience clearly shaped her ability to command a stage, and she used that to full effect. Consequently, her performance resonated with both nostalgia and authenticity.
Appearing at 54 Below—a venue known for top-tier musical talent—made the night even more significant. Ultimately, this Eve Plumb Broadway moment showed that her artistic journey is far from over and suggested that an exciting new chapter could still be ahead.