• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
do you remember

DoYouRemember?

The Home of Nostalgia

  • Celebrity News
    • Family
    • Obituaries
    • Life Behind the Fame
    • Icons
    • Celebrity Feuds
  • Entertainment
    • Cast
    • Showbiz Rewind
    • Music
    • Beauty & fashion
  • Stories
  • Celebrity Buzz!?
  • Sitcoms
    • Bewitched
    • Little Rascals
    • The Partridge Family
    • I Dream of Jeannie
    • All in the Family
    • MASH
    • Happy Days
    • Cheers
  • Celebrity Collections
  • About Us
  • Media
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • DMCA
  • Contact Us
  • Authors
Stories

Valerie Harper Was Fired From Her Own Sitcom—Then She Fought Back

by Dana Daly • Published November 20, 2026

Add as a preferred source on Google
Valerie Harper

Valerie Harper was fired from her NBC sitcom ‘Valerie’ in 1987 and written out in a car crash. Here is how her fight with Lorimar played out in court.


In the summer of 1987, Valerie Harper was the name in the title of a hit NBC sitcom. By that fall, the show had kept going without her, her character had been killed off in a car accident, and Sandy Duncan had moved into the Hogan family kitchen. The studio said Harper had walked away. Harper said she had been thrown out.

For a woman audiences had loved as Rhoda Morgenstern for nine seasons, it was a strange and public fall. What followed was a courtroom fight with Lorimar, the studio that made the show, and it ended with a jury deciding which side was telling the truth.

Related:

  1. Madonna’s Daughter Lourdes Leon Channels Famous Mom, Puts On Stunning Live Performance
  2. Priscilla Presley Stuns Fans With Throwback Bikini Photo That’s All ’70s Glamour

Rhoda Comes Home To Television

Valerie Harper in Rhoda
Valerie Harper in Rhoda / Everett Collection

Harper had already given TV one of its great sidekicks. She played Rhoda on The Mary Tyler Moore Show beginning in 1970 and won three Emmys in a row as supporting actress, from 1971 to 1973, before CBS gave Rhoda her own show in 1974. More than 52 million people watched Rhoda get married on Rhoda that fall, the Associated Press reported, and Harper won a fourth Emmy as lead actress. That old WJM newsroom has thinned out since, and you can see the Mary Tyler Moore Show cast members still with us here.

She also had a reputation for standing up for herself. Variety recalled in 2019 that she reportedly refused to come back for the second season of Rhoda until CBS raised her pay from $10,000 to $17,500 a week, and CBS paid. So when NBC premiered Valerie on March 1, 1986, with Harper as Valerie Hogan, a mother raising three sons while her airline pilot husband was often away, she came in as a star who knew her value. The oldest son, David, was played by a teenager named Jason Bateman.

By the spring of 1987, the trouble behind the cameras had started.

The Summer Valerie Hogan Disappeared

Sandy Duncan
Sandy Duncan (front center) in The Sandy Duncan Show, 1972 / Everett Collection

Harper wanted more money and, she said, the creative say she had been promised. Lorimar’s lawyer later told the jury she had demanded about $2.2 million a year, nearly double her salary, plus 35 percent of the profits, UPI reported. Harper’s side said the real fight was over the strong voice in scripts and direction that Lorimar had promised her when she helped develop the show.

On July 31, 1987, Harper sat out the filming of the new season’s first episode. Two days later she was back at work after patching things up with the producers. On August 7 she complained again, this time that her husband and fellow producer, Tony Cacciotti, had been left out of a writers’ meeting. Three days after that, Lorimar sent her a letter telling her not to come back.

When Valerie’s Family premiered that September, Valerie Hogan had died in an automobile accident, and the boys’ Aunt Sandy, played by Sandy Duncan, had moved in to help her brother raise them. Duncan wanted no part of the fight. “The story I got before I agreed to do the show was that Valerie had left the series,” she told UPI in October 1987. “The problems between Valerie and Lorimar have nothing to do with me. I refuse to be on the hot seat.”

Rumors went around that Harper had been jealous of her teenage co-star. She shot that down in a 1988 interview with TV Guide. “Jason was one of the first people I called when I learned I’d been fired,” she said.

A $70 Million Lawsuit Against Her

Valerie Harper 1974
Valerie Harper 1974 / Wikimedia Commons

The studio sued Harper and Cacciotti for $70 million, claiming she had broken her contract with repeated threats to quit. The couple countersued for $50 million and added NBC and producers Thomas Miller and Robert Boyett. Rather than wait years for a county courtroom, both sides paid a retired judge $15,000 a week to hear it, the Deseret News reported.

The trial got personal. Lorimar’s producers and a writer testified that Harper was volatile off the set, and they said they had worried about her mental health. Directors who worked with her said she was professional on the set. By the end, Lorimar had cut its claim to $313,000. Harper’s lawyer, Barry Langberg, told the jury the couple had been fired over Harper’s “pain in the neck demands for consultation and her big salary.”

“I think the only thing she didn’t do is be a nice little actress,” Langberg said in his closing argument, and he called the studio’s witnesses “two-faced.”

What The Jury Decided

HEART TRUTH FW10 NEW YORK 02/11/2010 / Wikipedia

On September 16, 1988, after four days of deliberation, the jury found that Lorimar had wrongfully fired Harper and her husband. It awarded the couple $1.85 million, according to both UPI and the Deseret News, with $1.63 million of it going to Harper. They were also awarded 12.5 percent of the show’s adjusted gross profits from the 1987 and 1988 seasons, money that would come due when the series was sold into syndication. Her claims against NBC were thrown out. Later accounts, including the AP’s 2019 obituary, put her damages at $1.4 million.

The show she had started kept going without her. It became The Hogan Family in 1988 and moved to CBS for one final season before it ended in 1991. Jason Bateman, one of the first people she called after her firing, went behind the camera on the series and became the youngest director ever to earn a Directors Guild credit, The Hollywood Reporter noted. Sandy Duncan, now 80, stayed with the Hogans until the end.

Harper kept working for three more decades. She was diagnosed with lung cancer in 2009, and in 2013 she announced that it had spread to the lining of her brain and that doctors had given her as little as three months to live. She lived six more years. Valerie Harper died in Los Angeles on August 30, 2019, at 80, eight days after her birthday, with Cacciotti and their daughter, Cristina, surviving her.

She wrote about the verdict in her 2013 memoir, I, Rhoda. “I felt vindicated,” she wrote. “I had beaten Lorimar and reclaimed my reputation.”

More Like This

Meryl Streep Makes Rare Appearance With All Her Children Including Famous Son-In-Law

77-Year-Old Meryl Streep’s 4 Kids Are All Grown Up. Here’s What They Do Now

Jennifer Landon

62-Year-Old Melissa Gilbert Says Michael Landon Blew Up Walnut Grove For A Reason That Was Never In The Script

Tom Hanks

70-Year-Old Tom Hanks’ 4 Kids Are All Grown Up, And One Followed Him Behind The Camera

Moonlighting

The Only ‘Moonlighting’ Cast Members Still Alive Today

About Dana Daly

Dana Daly is DoYouRemember’s Editorial Manager. She has written and edited nostalgia stories and YouTube scripts for the site since 2019.

  • View Author
  • Website
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
Previous Post:Meryl Streep Makes Rare Appearance With All Her Children Including Famous Son-In-Law77-Year-Old Meryl Streep’s 4 Kids Are All Grown Up. Here’s What They Do Now

Sidebar

Recommended

Lucille Ball

Lucille Ball And Desi Arnaz Were Really Married, But ‘I Love Lucy’ Still Put Lucy And Ricky In Twin Beds

One Day At A Time

The Only ‘One Day At A Time’ Cast Members Still Alive Today, Including One Who Is 88

James Garner

James Garner Beat Warner Bros. In Court To Leave ‘Maverick’, Then Roger Moore Took His Place


do you remember
  • About Us
  • Media
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • DMCA
  • Contact Us
  • Authors

  • Facebook
  • X
  • YouTube
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • Mail

© 2026 · All Rights Reserved · Powered by BizBudding