Every street has one, and on Bewitched she lived right across the road. For seven seasons Gladys Kravitz spent her afternoons peeking through the curtains at 1164 Morning Glory Circle, shrieking for her husband Abner to come see the flying vacuum cleaner, only to have him find nothing but an ordinary living room. Her name became shorthand for every nosy neighbor in America. Yet if you watched closely in the fall of 1966, you noticed something odd about the woman at the window. She had a different face.
The short answer is that the original Mrs. Kravitz, Alice Pearce, died of ovarian cancer on March 3, 1966, at just 48, and Sandra Gould took over the part that October. The longer answer is far sadder and stranger than a routine recast, because Pearce had known she was seriously ill before she ever filmed a single scene as Gladys, and she chose to keep working anyway.
Who Was The First Mrs. Kravitz?

Alice Pearce was born in New York City on October 16, 1917, and spent part of her childhood in Europe, where her father worked in international banking. After earning a drama degree from Sarah Lawrence College in 1940, she worked the nightclub circuit as a comedienne and landed in the original 1944 Broadway cast of On the Town. Gene Kelly liked her so much that when MGM filmed the musical in 1949, she was the only member of the stage cast brought along to Hollywood, playing the hapless blind date Lucy Schmeeler opposite Kelly and Frank Sinatra.
By the time Bewitched premiered on ABC in September 1964, Pearce was a familiar character face, and her Gladys was a little different from the one many viewers remember. Her version was nosy and easily rattled but good hearted underneath, and she was often genuinely friendly with Samantha. The humor came from Gladys being right about everything and believed by no one, least of all George Tobias as the long-suffering Abner. What the audience could not see was what Pearce was carrying with her every day on the set.
What Was Alice Pearce Keeping From The Cast?

Shortly before she was offered the role, Pearce had surgery, and that operation was how doctors discovered her ovarian cancer. According to Wikipedia’s account of her life and a 2025 Woman’s World feature by Ed Gross, she was already facing a terminal diagnosis when she signed on, and she told almost no one. “She was a very private person and she didn’t tell them about her diagnosis,” her biographer Fredrick Tucker told the magazine. “And she literally worked until she could not stand up.”
For a while, nobody could tell. Tucker said she looked healthy through the first season and the very beginning of the second, but then the weight began to fall away. “She was painfully thin and, to bulk her up, the wardrobe department outfitted her with additional layers of clothing,” Bewitched historian Herbie J. Pilato recalled. Pop culture historian Geoffrey Mark put it more simply: “Alice wanted to work. She didn’t want to let her illness define her.” If you rewatch the season two episodes today, the change is hard to miss, which raises the obvious question of how the show kept Gladys on screen at all.
How Did ‘Bewitched’ Cover For Gladys When She Was Gone?

The last episode Pearce filmed was “Baby’s First Paragraph,” in which Endora gives baby Tabitha the power to talk just to shut Gladys up about her bragging nephew. It aired on March 10, 1966, one week after Pearce died. The episode guides at Wikipedia and TVMaze both list that date, which means many viewers watched her last turn as Gladys without knowing she was gone.
The writers had already begun working around her absence. In the two-part “Follow That Witch,” which aired that April, Gladys was said to be away visiting her mother, and Abner’s sister Harriet moved in to keep him company. Harriet was played by Mary Grace Canfield, whom Green Acres fans knew as Ralph the carpenter, and before long she saw something peculiar across the street herself. She came around to her sister-in-law’s suspicions, and Abner was no more willing to believe her than he had been to believe his wife. Harriet bought the show time, but everyone knew Gladys herself would have to return.
Why Did Sandra Gould Get The Part?

The first choice was not Sandra Gould at all. According to Pilato, William Asher and Elizabeth Montgomery went to Alice Ghostley, who later joined the show as the bumbling maid Esmeralda. Ghostley turned them down because she had been friends with Pearce and felt uncomfortable stepping into her shoes. Executive producer Harry Ackerman then suggested Gould, a radio veteran he had known for years. “I thought she would be perfect for the role of Gladys Kravitz,” Ackerman said, as quoted by Pilato.
Gould was born in Brooklyn on July 23, 1916, and audiences of the 1940s knew her voice from radio, where she spent four years as the man-hungry Miss Duffy on Duffy’s Tavern. She was also a friend of Pearce’s, and she came to the role only a year after losing her own husband, broadcasting executive Larry Berns, who died in 1965. Her first episode as Gladys was “Endora Moves in for a Spell,” which aired October 20, 1966.
Gould played the part very differently. Her Gladys was louder, sharper and openly determined to expose Samantha, and Montgomery was not a fan. Pilato reported that in 1989 she said, “I never wanted [Sandra Gould] to play Mrs. Kravitz,” and that she found Gould too abrasive for the part. Viewers felt otherwise. Gould stayed for 29 episodes through the seventh season and even brought Gladys back in 1977 for “The Arrival of Nancy,” an episode of the spinoff Tabitha. She later turned up on The Brady Bunch, Punky Brewster and Friends, and she died in Burbank on July 20, 1999, three days short of her 83rd birthday, after a stroke that followed heart surgery, according to Variety.
The loss of Pearce was not the only time the show had to say goodbye to someone it loved. Two years later Bewitched lost Marion Lorne, and Aunt Clara simply vanished from the series the same quiet way. But Pearce’s story had one more chapter, and it came five months before Gould ever stepped up to the window.
What Happened At The 1966 Emmys?

On May 22, 1966, the television industry gathered at the Hollywood Palladium for the 18th Primetime Emmy Awards, hosted by Danny Kaye and Bill Cosby. Pearce had been nominated for Outstanding Performance by an Actress in a Supporting Role in a Comedy, up against Rose Marie of The Dick Van Dyke Show and her own Bewitched co-star Agnes Moorehead.
She won. The Television Academy still lists it as her one and only nomination and her one and only Emmy, and it was accepted by her husband, the stage director Paul Davis, whom she had married in September 1964, the same month Bewitched went on the air.
“It was a bittersweet moment when Pearce, who was nominated for an Emmy for her role, won that year, posthumously,” Pilato said. That spring the Emmy belonged to the neighbor nobody on Morning Glory Circle ever believed.





