• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
do you remember

DoYouRemember?

The Home of Nostalgia

  • Celebrity News
    • Family
    • Obituaries
    • Life Behind the Fame
    • Icons
    • Celebrity Feuds
  • Entertainment
    • Cast
    • Showbiz Rewind
    • Music
    • Beauty & fashion
  • Stories
  • Celebrity Buzz!?
  • Sitcoms
    • Bewitched
    • Little Rascals
    • The Partridge Family
    • I Dream of Jeannie
    • All in the Family
    • MASH
    • Happy Days
    • Cheers
  • Celebrity Collections
  • About Us
  • Media
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • DMCA
  • Contact Us
  • Authors
Stories

William Demarest Took Over As Uncle Charley On ‘My Three Sons’, Because William Frawley Couldn’t Pass The Studio’s Physical

by Dana Daly • Published November 18, 2026

Add as a preferred source on Google
William Frawley
William Frawley / Everett Collection

William Frawley’s Bub left ‘My Three Sons’ for Ireland in 1965 and never came back. What the studio’s insurance doctor found, and how Uncle Charley moved in.

For four and a half seasons of My Three Sons, the man in the apron at the Douglas house was William Frawley, the same gravel-voiced Fred Mertz who had spent six years next door to Lucy and Ricky. As Michael Francis “Bub” O’Casey, the boys’ grandfather on their late mother’s side, he cooked, scolded and fretted over Fred MacMurray’s three sons. Then, in January 1965, Bub packed a bag for Ireland, and a week later his brother Charley showed up at the door and never left.

The short answer to why it happened is Frawley’s health. He was 77, he had been slowing down on the set for some time, and when the cast went through the physical the studio required for its yearly insurance, he did not pass. Stanley Livingston, who played Chip, still remembers what the doctor said. The show sent Bub overseas instead of killing him off, and William Demarest, a 72-year-old movie veteran and a longtime friend of MacMurray’s, took over the kitchen as Uncle Charley for the rest of the run.

Related:

  1. 60 Years After ‘Dark Shadows’ Changed Daytime TV, Who Is Still Alive?
  2. No One From ‘The Rifleman’ Main Cast Is Still Alive Today, Including The Boy Who Played Mark McCain

Why Did Bub Suddenly Fly Off To Ireland?

William Frawley, Fred MacMurray, Tim Considine, Don Grady and Stanley Livingston in My Three Sons
William Frawley, Fred MacMurray and their TV sons in My Three Sons / Everett Collection

If you were watching ABC on Thursday night, January 7, 1965, the goodbye barely registered as one. In “A Woman’s Work,” Bub flies off to Ireland to see his elderly aunt, and Steve Douglas cheerfully volunteers to run the house while he is gone. TV Guide’s episode guide notes that it was Frawley’s final appearance as Bub because of his failing health. His excuse, according to the series’ Wikipedia history and IMDb, was Aunt Kate’s 104th birthday.

One week later, on January 14, came “Here Comes Charley.” Steve, worn out from juggling the house and his engineering job, starts interviewing housekeepers. Then Bub’s brother Charley, a crusty old sailor, drops by for a visit and simply stays. Bub got the odd mention for the rest of that season, but he never came home.

What viewers didn’t see was how long the trouble had been building behind the scenes.

What Was Happening To William Frawley On The Set?

Fred MacMurray, William Frawley and Stanley Livingston in My Three Sons
Fred MacMurray, William Frawley and Stanley Livingston in My Three Sons / TV Guide / courtesy Everett Collection

Frawley had gone straight from I Love Lucy to My Three Sons when it premiered on September 29, 1960, and he loved the part. “Bub’s a lovable old coot and just my type of guy,” he told syndicated writer Charles J. Leavy in 1961. “I think I’d like Bub if ever I met him face to face.”

The way the show was made was harder on him. MacMurray’s deal let him shoot all of his scenes in two concentrated blocks, about 65 working days a year, and everyone else filled in around him. “We were shooting 3-4 shows a day to get his scenes in,” Livingston told The Los Angeles Beat in 2014. Frawley, who had filmed Lucy in story order, reportedly never got comfortable jumping between episodes.

By the fifth season, age and drink were catching up with him. Mental Floss recounted that a prop man lay on the floor out of camera range to tap his shoe and keep him awake for afternoon close-ups. Tim Considine, who played eldest son Mike, told Page Six in 2022 that one of his jobs was fetching Frawley back from Nickodell, a popular hangout where actors and crew went to drink. “Sometimes he’d fall asleep in the middle of a scene,” Considine said, as Fox News reported, adding that the writers kept Bub on his feet with chores like sweeping. He still called Frawley “a terrific guy.”

None of that got him fired. The insurance doctor did.

What Did The Studio Doctor Find?

Barry Livingston, Stanley Livingston
Barry Livingston, Stanley Livingston / Everett Collection

Because My Three Sons filmed out of order, the studio needed every actor insured for the whole year, and that meant an annual physical. “They couldn’t get him insured,” Livingston told The Los Angeles Beat. In his telling, the examining doctor came out and said, “Hey, I can’t hear this guy’s heartbeat. He’s not gonna make it.” He gave the same answer to The Showbiz Wizard in 2012. “Frawley was having some health problems and the studio basically couldn’t get him insured,” he said. “They had to let him go and needed to replace that character.”

Lucy historian Geoffrey Mark gave a gentler version to writer Ed Gross in 2024. “Bill had a stroke, and it was decided mutually that the work was too much for him,” Mark said, explaining that Frawley could still walk and talk but had lost his comic timing and energy.

Whichever version you favor, Frawley didn’t want to go. Livingston’s official site says he “really enjoyed working on the show and did not want to leave.” Neither MacMurray nor producer Don Fedderson ever gave a public account of the decision that we could find. Livingston, then 14, lost the man he ate lunch with every day. “I didn’t have a grandfather and he never had any kids,” he told The Showbiz Wizard.

The bigger problem for the producers was who could possibly stand in that kitchen next.

How Did William Demarest Become Uncle Charley?

William Demarest as Uncle Charley with the cast of My Three Sons
William Demarest as Uncle Charley with the cast of My Three Sons / Everett Collection

The answer was already in MacMurray’s Rolodex. William Demarest, born February 27, 1892, was a Preston Sturges regular who earned an Oscar nomination for The Jolson Story in 1946. He had also made several films with MacMurray, starting with Hands Across the Table in 1935, and the two were friends. “Fred MacMurray worked with William Demarest quite a bit,” Livingston told The Showbiz Wizard. “Somehow he came to their attention as he was so much like Frawley.”

Like Frawley, he was a bark-first curmudgeon with a soft center, and the writers made him family rather than a hired hand. Making Charley Bub’s brother kept the boys’ late mother’s family running the house. On set, though, not everyone saw the two old men as interchangeable. Don Grady, who played Robbie, said on CBS’s The Early Show in 2009 that Demarest was the crankier of the pair. “Frawley was a kick,” he said.

The swap worked anyway. When ABC declined to pay for color and the show moved to CBS in the fall of 1965, Uncle Charley went with it, and he stayed through the final episode in 1972. “He was probably in 7 years of it,” Livingston said. “So he was on longer than William Frawley anyway.”

Did William Frawley Ever Come Back?

Lucille Ball, Desi Arnaz and William Frawley
Lucille Ball, Desi Arnaz and William Frawley on I Love Lucy / Everett Collection

He never returned to My Three Sons. His last time in front of a camera came on October 25, 1965, with a brief cameo on Lucille Ball’s The Lucy Show in “Lucy and the Countess Have a Horse Guest,” according to his Wikipedia biography and Geoffrey Mark. “If Frawley liked you… he could be surprisingly thoughtful,” Barry Livingston, now 72, wrote in his memoir, The Importance of Being Ernie, remembering the longboard the old man gave Stanley when surfing took off.

On March 3, 1966, about 14 months after Bub flew to Ireland, Frawley suffered a fatal heart attack while walking on Hollywood Boulevard. He was 79. “He was just walking. He had a heart attack,” Stanley Livingston said. MacMurray and Fedderson served as pallbearers alongside Desi Arnaz, and Frawley was buried at San Fernando Mission Cemetery. Livingston, now 75, believes losing the show took more out of him than anyone realized. With no wife or children waiting at home, he told Ed Gross, once the series was gone “he really had nothing to live for.”

The date carried one more echo for the Douglas family. Tim Considine, the son who used to walk Frawley back from Nickodell, died on March 3, 2022, at 81, exactly 56 years to the day after the man he called “a terrific guy.” You can see who from the Douglas house is still with us in our look at the surviving My Three Sons cast.

More Like This

83-Year-Old Robert De Niro’s 7 Kids Are All Grown Up, And His Youngest Arrived When He Was 79

Judy Norton

‘The Waltons’ Star Judy Norton Lost Her TV Husband At Pearl Harbor, Then He Came Back With A New Face

No One From

Who Is Still Alive From The Original ‘Perry Mason’ Main Cast Today?

LEE and FARRAH FAWCETT MAJORS

Farrah Fawcett Quit ‘Charlie’s Angels’ After Just One Season, And A $7 Million Lawsuit Brought Jill Munroe Back

About Dana Daly

Dana Daly is DoYouRemember’s Editorial Manager. She has written and edited nostalgia stories and YouTube scripts for the site since 2019.

  • View Author
  • Website
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
Previous Post:83-Year-Old Robert De Niro’s 7 Kids Are All Grown Up, And His Youngest Arrived When He Was 79

Sidebar

Recommended

Johnny Cash’s 5 Kids Are All Grown Up, And One Daughter Married Her Dad’s Guitar Player

83-Year-Old Christopher Walken Credits One Decision With His Wife For His Entire Career

William Shatner

95-Year-Old William Shatner’s ‘Star Trek’ Was Saved By Fans In 1968, Then Came Bad News


do you remember
  • About Us
  • Media
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • DMCA
  • Contact Us
  • Authors

  • Facebook
  • X
  • YouTube
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • Mail

© 2026 · All Rights Reserved · Powered by BizBudding