When Barnaby Jones premiered on CBS on January 28, 1973, nobody on the set had lower hopes for it than the woman playing the hero’s daughter-in-law. Lee Meriwether had already been Miss America and Catwoman by then, but she walked onto Buddy Ebsen’s new detective show braced for it to fold. “When I came into the series, I didn’t expect much,” she told United Features in an interview that MeTV recently dug back up.
The show ran eight seasons and 178 episodes, and it earned her two Golden Globe nominations and an Emmy nomination along the way. Yet the longer it lasted, the more uneasy she became, and near the end she was quietly telling herself she might not come back. Her reason had nothing to do with ratings, money or Buddy Ebsen, and it says a lot about the woman millions of us watched every week.
How Did Miss America End Up in a Catsuit?

Meriwether was born in Los Angeles on May 27, 1935, which makes her 91 today. She was a 19-year-old student at City College of San Francisco when she won Miss San Francisco and then Miss California, and on September 11, 1954, she was crowned Miss America 1955 in Atlantic City. It was the first year the pageant aired live on national television, according to Wikipedia’s history of the contest, so a whole country watched her win. She very nearly stayed home. “I almost didn’t go to Atlantic City, because my father passed away,” she told Pageantry magazine, adding that her mother and pageant director Lenore Slaughter talked her into going.
The crown opened doors, but the role that made her a pop culture fixture came a dozen years later and on almost no notice. When Julie Newmar couldn’t play Catwoman in the 1966 Batman feature film because of another movie, Meriwether got the call. “Get over to 20th Century Fox. You’re going to read for Catwoman,” she remembered being told, in a 2018 interview with Fox News. “There wasn’t much time to work on it!” The movie opened on July 30, 1966, and she called Adam West “a sweet, nice man. A gentleman.” She is one of the stars still with us from that era, as we noted in our look at the surviving ’60s Batman cast. Busy years on The Time Tunnel and Star Trek followed, and then came the job that would keep her employed for most of the 1970s.
Why Did She Expect So Little From ‘Barnaby Jones’?

Barnaby Jones did not look like a sure thing on paper. Buddy Ebsen was 64 when it premiered, barely two years removed from The Beverly Hillbillies, and he was playing a retired private eye who goes back to work after his son Hal is murdered on a case. The very first episode, “Requiem for a Son,” borrowed William Conrad from Cannon to help launch it. Meriwether played Betty Jones, Hal’s widow, who joins her father-in-law at the agency to find her husband’s killer and then stays on.
Her doubts were not really about the show, though. She told United Features she had a lifelong habit of bracing for disappointment. “I’m defeated before I’ve begun,” she said, and she traced the habit all the way back to Atlantic City. “Before it even began, I had picked the girls who I was sure would win,” she recalled. “Though I wanted to win desperately, I never let myself think about it.” She won anyway, and something similar was about to happen on CBS.
What Happened When the Show Kept Getting Renewed?

Critics were not kind to Barnaby Jones at first, but viewers liked the soft-spoken detective and his sharp daughter-in-law, and the renewals kept coming. Betty grew from secretary into a real investigator, and by the later seasons Ebsen anchored about 12 episodes a year while Meriwether and Mark Shera, who joined in 1976 as young cousin J.R. Jones, each carried about six. Her work earned Golden Globe nominations for Best Actress in a Drama Series in 1975 and 1976, plus a 1977 Emmy nomination for Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Drama Series.
Off camera she became the set’s morale officer. TV Guide reported that the crew nicknamed her “Our Cheerleader,” partly because she led the cheers and bought the team shirts for a studio softball game, according to MeTV. “My folks used to tell me that if you want to get anywhere in this world you have to work for it,” she said. “I guess that message took because if I don’t have a goal, I get lazy. I hate being lazy.” That cheerful drive is exactly why her next confession surprised people.
Why Was She Ready to Walk Away From a Hit?

By the eighth season, the show that she expected to fail was still going strong, and that was the problem. “I frankly hadn’t expected Barnaby to run as long as it has. It’s been too good,” she told United Features. “It’s been so good all this time, and I’m telling myself I don’t think I’ll do another year.” Then she named the real reason. “I don’t know what it is about me that I don’t feel I deserve good things to come my way.”
She never had to make the call. CBS confirmed in May 1980 that Barnaby Jones was done after its April 3 finale, and producer Roy Stork later explained that “Buddy always had his eye on the eight-year mark.” Ebsen, who died on July 6, 2003, at 95, got the run he wanted. Meriwether had a plan for what came next, and it did not involve another grind of a weekly series. She had set up her own production company and hoped to produce a show, she told United Features in a separate interview that MeTV also revisited, “But I’d never hire myself to star in a series. It’s too tiring and time-consuming.” She kept working instead, on stage and in guest roles, and she later stepped in for a time as Ruth Martin on All My Children.
In 2024, word came that she is living with Alzheimer’s disease. General Hospital star Maurice Benard spoke about it on his State of Mind show after an interview with her daughter, as reported by Soaps.com and Soap Hub, and he said he wanted viewers to see “what Alzheimer’s does to someone.” Her old show has found a new audience in the meantime, with MeTV airing Barnaby Jones reruns since 2019. The young woman who once refused to let herself hope for the crown is still getting mail from viewers who loved her. “I still get fan mail from all over the world,” she told Fox News in 2018, and a good share of those letters were written by people who first met her as Betty Jones.






Lassie Was Always A Girl On ‘Lassie’, But Rudd Weatherwax Had A Reason For Casting Only Males