• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
do you remember

DoYouRemember?

The Home of Nostalgia

  • Celebrity News
    • Family
    • Obituaries
    • Life Behind the Fame
    • Icons
    • Celebrity Feuds
  • Entertainment
    • Cast
    • Showbiz Rewind
    • Music
    • Beauty & fashion
  • Stories
  • Celebrity Buzz!?
  • Sitcoms
    • Bewitched
    • Little Rascals
    • The Partridge Family
    • I Dream of Jeannie
    • All in the Family
    • MASH
    • Happy Days
    • Cheers
  • Celebrity Collections
  • About Us
  • Media
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • DMCA
  • Contact Us
  • Authors
Stories

Another Actor Was About To Be Cast As Gomer Pyle Before Andy Griffith Brought In Jim Nabors

by Dana Daly • Published November 17, 2026

Add as a preferred source on Google
Andy Griffith with an inset of Andy Griffith and Jim Nabors
Andy Griffith and Jim Nabors / Everett Collection

Andy Griffith saw Jim Nabors in a Santa Monica nightclub and changed ‘The Andy Griffith Show’ casting plans. Meet the actor who almost played Gomer Pyle.

In 1962, producer Aaron Ruben had the role of a Mayberry gas station attendant just about filled. The actor he had in mind was a trained professional who had read the part well, and the deal was close enough that Ruben later admitted, “I was about to hire him.” Then Andy Griffith walked in after rehearsal with a question that changed the course of three television careers.

“Have you already hired the guy to play the filling-station attendant?” Griffith asked, as Ruben recalled to author Daniel de Visé for his book Andy & Don: The Making of a Friendship and a Classic American TV Show. Ruben said he was about to. “Before you do, would you meet somebody?” The somebody was a skinny singer from Sylacauga, Alabama, named Jim Nabors, and the actor who lost the part would take it harder than anyone in Mayberry ever knew.

Related:

  1. 12+ Things You Didn’t Know About The Rockefeller Center Christmas Tree
  2. Simon Cowell Opens Up About Why Bob Dylan’s Voice Wouldn’t Make It On His Shows

Where Did Andy Griffith Find Jim Nabors?

Jim Nabors
Jim Nabors and Frank Sutton / Everett Collection

Nabors was not an actor at all in 1962. He was working as a film cutter at NBC by day, and at night he sang and clowned at The Horn, a small cabaret in Santa Monica where performers tried out their acts. Between songs, he slipped into a sweet, slow-talking Southern boy whose innocence made audiences howl. Griffith happened to catch the show, and he never forgot it.

“I went crazy watching him,” Griffith told the Reporter-Dispatch in 1965. “I asked my producer to give him a chance to audition for the role of the filling station operator. That part was just about set, but Jim got a chance, and that was the beginning of Gomer Pyle.” Nabors told the story the same way decades later. “Andy Griffith saw me in the club, and he liked my character,” he said in a 2014 interview with Indianapolis Monthly. “Sure enough, he called about two weeks later and said come down. I read for the part and got it.”

Ruben told de Visé that what Nabors “lacked in professionalism and experience he made up for with a certain naive charm.” Nabors himself was terrified. He confessed to the producers that it was the first time he had ever acted, and Griffith looked over and told him, “Well, hell, ain’t nothing to it.” Gomer pulled into Mayberry in “Man in a Hurry,” which aired January 14, 1963, and what was meant to be a one-shot part kept getting renewed.

How Far Did Gomer Go After Mayberry?

Andy Griffith
Andy Griffith at the TV Land Awards in 2004 / ImageCollect

Viewers took to Gomer so quickly that CBS gave him a show of his own. The pilot for Gomer Pyle, U.S.M.C. aired as the season four finale of The Andy Griffith Show on May 18, 1964, and the series ran five seasons and 150 episodes. Gomer’s catchphrases followed Nabors for life. “I wish I had registered ‘Golly’ and ‘Shazam,'” he joked to Indianapolis Monthly. “They’ve become bywords in American vernacular.”

Griffith saw more in his discovery than a catchphrase. “He’s got a marvelous singing voice and a great sense of comedy,” he said in 1965, adding that Nabors had “a lot more to offer than Gomer Pyle.” He was right. Nabors walked away from the Marine Corps comedy in 1969 while it was still a hit and hosted The Jim Nabors Hour until 1971, and his booming baritone rendition of “Back Home Again in Indiana” became a ritual at the Indianapolis 500 from 1972 until his farewell in 2014. He died at his Honolulu home on November 30, 2017, at 87, according to the Associated Press and NPR. Griffith had died five years earlier, on July 3, 2012, at his home in Manteo, North Carolina, at 86. So who was the pro Ruben almost hired?

Who Was The Actor Who Lost Gomer Pyle?

George Lindsey
Gordie Tapp, George Lindsey, Minnie Pearl and Gailard Sartain in Hee Haw / Everett Collection

It was George Lindsey, the future Goober. Born December 17, 1928, in Fairfield, Alabama, Lindsey was certain the gas station job was his. The Encyclopedia of Alabama notes that he “originally tried out for the part of Gomer Pyle, which went to fellow Alabamian Jim Nabors,” and his 2012 obituaries described a part that slipped away at the last minute. “I really wanted that part of Gomer,” Lindsey told the Birmingham Post-Herald in 1966.

In his 1995 memoir Goober in a Nutshell, he admitted that watching Gomer’s first episode at home was more than he could take. “I jumped up from my chair in an absolute rage and kicked the tube out of the television set,” he wrote, screaming, “That’s my part, that’s my part, that’s my part!” For a long while afterward, he wrote, he could not bring himself to speak to Nabors.

The producers had not forgotten him, though. Gomer had been talking about a cousin named Goober for more than a year, and in 1964 Lindsey auditioned to finally put a face to the name, and got it. Goober first appeared in “Fun Girls” on April 13, 1964, which turned out to be the only episode where the two Pyle cousins shared the screen. “I just did one show with him,” Lindsey told writer Pat Gallagher in his final interview, published by HuffPost in May 2012. “His last show was my first show. He went to the Marines, you know.”

Goober stayed in Mayberry through the end of The Andy Griffith Show and into Mayberry R.F.D., and in 1972 Lindsey joined Hee Haw, where he spent the next two decades swapping corny jokes in Kornfield Kounty. You can catch up with his old castmates in our look at the Hee Haw stars still with us.

Lindsey died in Nashville on May 6, 2012, at 83, and Griffith followed him less than two months later. In that last interview, he had nothing but praise for the man whose nightclub hunch had cost him Gomer. “He was a great leader and the best script constructionist that I’ve ever worked with,” Lindsey said of Griffith. “He was not Andy Taylor. He was Andy Griffith.”

More Like This

83-Year-Old Chevy Chase’s 3 Daughters Are All Grown Up, And His Baby Grandson Is Already Dressed For ‘Christmas Vacation’

Danny DeVito and Rhea Perlman

Danny DeVito And Rhea Perlman Split In 2017—But It’s A Bit More Complicated Than That

The Only ‘Laugh-In’ Cast Members Still Alive Today

Kenny Rogers and his wife Wanda Miller

Kenny Rogers’ Twin Sons Are 22 Now, And His 3 Older Kids Took Very Different Paths

About Dana Daly

Dana Daly is DoYouRemember’s Editorial Manager. She has written and edited nostalgia stories and YouTube scripts for the site since 2019.

  • View Author
  • Website
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
Previous Post:83-Year-Old Chevy Chase’s 3 Daughters Are All Grown Up, And His Baby Grandson Is Already Dressed For ‘Christmas Vacation’

Sidebar

Recommended

alice-pearce-elizabeth-montgomery-bewitched

Alice Pearce Played Nosy Gladys Kravitz On ‘Bewitched’ While Hiding A Heartbreaking Secret From The Cast

Sally Field

80-Year-Old Sally Field’s Oldest Son Co-Wrote ‘Top Gun: Maverick.’ Here’s What Her 3 Sons Are Doing Today

Knots Landing

The Only ‘Knots Landing’ Cast Members Still Alive Today


do you remember
  • About Us
  • Media
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • DMCA
  • Contact Us
  • Authors

  • Facebook
  • X
  • YouTube
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • Mail

© 2026 · All Rights Reserved · Powered by BizBudding