Carrie Underwood‘s return to American Idol, this time as a judge, was expected to be a big comeback. But instead of celebration, her presence has sparked some drama and debate. Crew members claim the country star’s approach and fit haven’t quite clicked, despite her history as one of the show’s most successful winners.
Even with the criticism, one voice has always supported her: Luke Bryan. The longtime friend and fellow judge has been her biggest cheerleader, always encouraging her as she gets used to her new role.
Fans have criticized Carrie Underwood’s judging style
View this post on Instagram
Some American Idol staff have said that while Carrie started strong, her judging style has gradually sparked some reactions. She has been described as distant and hard to connect with; there’s concern that she hasn’t yet gotten the full weight of the role or its impact on the show’s reputation and crew behind the scenes.
Despite the criticism coming from left and right, Luke Bryan has consistently stood by her. He has stepped in multiple times to support and defend her. He acknowledges that being a judge isn’t easy but believes she has the heart and presence to grow into it fully.
Bryan describes her as having “the best soul and heart”
Their friendship isn’t just about the spotlight. It is one built on years of having each other’s backs in Nashville, even long before fame came at all. Although they have known each other for years, it was when they teamed up on American Idol that their connection really took off.
Bryan has openly admired her growth, reminding everyone that mastering any role takes time and patience. He described her as having “the best soul and heart,” especially when interacting with contestants. And even though she’s still finding her footing, his belief in her ability to shine remains unshaken.