Somewhere in the middle of a long, easy conversation on Monday’s episode of Conan O’Brien Needs a Friend, talk turned to whether either man had ever looked down the barrel of a gun. Conan O’Brien said he hadn’t. Dustin Hoffman, now 89, said he had, and then he told the story of the night it happened, a story he set squarely “in my youth.”
Hoffman was on the podcast to talk about Look at Me, the memoir he wrote with New Yorker writer Ariel Levy, which arrives in bookstores today, November 10. The gun story wasn’t the plug, but it’s the one everyone is talking about. The night Dustin Hoffman was held at gunpoint involves a married woman, a husband who was supposed to be asleep, and a few seconds the actor still describes as clearly as if they happened last week.
What Did Dustin Hoffman Tell Conan O’Brien?
“I was having an affair with a married woman,” Hoffman said, as quoted by the Press Association in The Irish News. “And she thought that once her husband went to sleep, that he stayed asleep. And I was invited to come over after he went to sleep.”
The husband, it turned out, was a lighter sleeper than anyone had planned for. Hoffman described the two of them “having a festival of sorts” when the door opened. “He walked in with a gun,” he said. “And he pointed at me.”
He never named the woman or her husband, and he never said what year it was or how old he was. That leaves one clue worth following, which is what young Dustin Hoffman’s life looked like back then.
Who Was Dustin Hoffman Before He Was Famous?
He was, by most accounts, broke and sleeping on floors. Hoffman, born in Los Angeles on August 8, 1937, met Gene Hackman at the Pasadena Playhouse. “I met Gene in acting school, at the Pasadena Playhouse, when he was 27 and I was 19,” he said in a tribute reported by Rolling Stone in February 2025, the week Hackman died. “We used to play congas together on the roof, trying to be like our hero Marlon Brando.” Legend has it the two of them were voted the students least likely to succeed.
When Hackman moved to New York, Hoffman followed him there and landed in Hackman’s small apartment. “I slept on his floor because he had this small bedroom and then, this little teeny bit larger room,” Hoffman recalled while promoting Runaway Jury, the 2003 courtroom thriller that finally put the two old friends on screen together. He was supposed to stay for two days and stayed about three weeks. “Gene lent me to Bob Duvall because it was the only way he could get me out of his apartment,” Hoffman joked. Hackman’s version was blunter. Hoffman, he said, was the worst housemate: “We had to hose the rooms down and sweep them out.”
Hoffman spent close to a decade doing odd jobs between parts, including selling toys at Macy’s, which he told Conan he treated as an acting exercise. Hackman once summed up those lean years for all three of them: “The idea that any of us would do well in films simply didn’t occur to us. We just wanted to work.” The three of them all got there, and Hoffman is now the last one left. Hackman died in February 2025 and Duvall in February 2026, both at 95, and both men appear in the pages of his new book.
Why Is Dustin Hoffman Telling These Stories Now?
Because Look at Me is the first time he has turned the camera fully on himself. Simon & Schuster describes it as a look back across nearly six decades, from Greenwich Village in the 1960s to a clash with Steve McQueen and run-ins with Laurence Olivier and Mike Nichols. An excerpt in The New Yorker on October 31 caused a stir of its own, because Hoffman wrote that making The Graduate was a “terrible experience” that left him not wanting to “make another movie again for the rest of my life.” We dug into the movie’s famously ambiguous finish in our look at how The Graduate cast and author read that ending.
Longtime fans will catch a small irony here. The role that made Hoffman a star in 1967 was Benjamin Braddock, a nervous young man caught in an affair with a married woman, Mrs. Robinson, whose husband eventually finds out. On screen, the angry husband shows up with words. In Hoffman’s real story, the husband showed up with something else.
His love life settled down long ago. He has been married to Lisa Gottsegen since October 1980, and we told the story of his first wife, Anne Byrne, and the night he thanked divorce on the Golden Globes stage just last week. The gun story belongs to a younger, wilder man, and Hoffman told Conan exactly how that night ended.
How Did Dustin Hoffman Get Away After Being Held at Gunpoint?
The husband didn’t fire, and he didn’t say much. “He said, I remember what he says, ‘Get out, get out,'” Hoffman told Conan. Then he described what those seconds felt like from the wrong end of the gun.
“When you have a gun pointed at you, first of all, that hole is much bigger than the actual hole,” he said. “You realize how, any second, he’s gonna pull that trigger. His finger is on the trigger and you think, any second.” The thought that followed was simple. “I’m gonna die, I’m gonna die the next second.”
So he did what the man told him to do. “You will do anything, you know, to avoid getting killed,” Hoffman said, and he walked out of that house in one piece. He didn’t share anything more about the woman or whether he ever saw her again, and he seemed happy to leave it there. For a man who spent his career making audiences believe every nervous breath Benjamin Braddock took, it may be the most convincing scene he ever played, and there was no second take.
Willie Nelson, 93, Reveals Wife Annie’s Unforgettable Answer When He Begged Her to Let Him Go During COVID